2020/11/24

Flightless birds are hard evidence against evolution

Several birds have lost their ability to fly due to genetic mutations - Genetic erosion is a biological fact

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/how-clumsy-galapagos-cormorant-lost-its-flight

Excerpt:"Fernandina, the westernmost island in the Galapagos archipelago, is a pristine spot. It is also a place regularly inundated by lava flows that set its waters boiling. Yet that hasn’t stopped one odd bird from calling Fernandina home: the world’s only flightless cormorant. Now, a new study proposes an explanation for how the stumpy-winged seabird lost its ability to fly—through more than a dozen genetic anomalies that it shares with humans suffering from a variety of rare skeletal disorders.

Since many developmental genes shoulder multiple roles, Kruglyak’s team reasoned that a genetic factor for flightlessness would not be found in a protein mutation, which could lead to a fatal outcome. Instead, they began searching for irregularities in the vast segments of DNA between genes called the noncoding regions, hoping to find clues about how the same genes might be regulated differently.

But that comparison yielded no results, so they turned back to the coding regions—the genes that produce proteins—to search for mutations that would change a protein’s ability to function normally. They discovered about a dozen mutated genes in the Galapagos cormorants known to trigger rare skeletal disorders in humans called ciliopathies, often characterized by misshapen skulls, short limbs, and small ribcages. Since Galapagos cormorants have short wings and an unusually small sternum, the researchers suspected this link was significant, they write today in Science.

Ciliopathies in humans arise from gene mutations affecting cilia—the microscopic hairlike extensions used to convey chemical messages between cells that control vertebrate development. When those signals go off-kilter, the body can grow in a visibly abnormal way. Sensenbrenner syndrome is one example, a rare condition reported in only a few dozen people characterized by an elongated skull, short limbs and fingers, a narrow chest, and respiratory problems. One of the genes linked to Sensenbrenner, called Ift122, was similarly mutated in the Galapagos cormorant. Another gene responsible for cilia production, Cux1, seemed to play a role in the cormorant’s stubby wings."

https://www.darwinthenandnow.com/archives/8666/galapagos-icon-of-evolution/

Excerpt: "Darwin, however, may have never seen the flightless Galapagos cormorants. During his five-year global expedition, while Darwin only mentions the cormorants (pictured) five-times in his Voyage of the Beagle, but during his thirty-five-day survey of the Galapagos Islands in 1835, the flightless cormorant is never mentioned."

My comment: It's very likely that Galápagos cormorants have lost their ability to fly just recently.

Known examples of flightless birds:

Emu

Ostrich

Rhea

Penguin

Cassowary

Kiwi

Kagu

Takahe

Weka

Steamer duck

Red junglefowl

Flightless cormorant


My comment: There is no evidence that assumed evolution could produce novel structures. How could a random chance develop an ability to fly? The theory of evolution has no scientific basis. Instead, we can observe rapid genetic degradation that can be called devolution. Most of these flightless birds are classified as critically endangered or vulnerable according to IUCN red list.